Oak or Maple Hardwood Floors: Which One Should I Choose?

A pale hard maple hardwood plank next to a warmer red oak plank with a more visible grain

You have decided on real hardwood. Then the next question comes: oak or maple? Both are sold in many colours. The difference is in how hard they are, how the grain looks, and the natural colour of the wood.

Short answer: Hard maple is a bit harder than red oak, with a smooth, delicate grain and a light, clean colour. Red oak has a more open, visible grain and warmer tones from gold to dark brown. If you want a calm, light floor, look at maple. If you like seeing the wood grain, look at oak. Both are durable choices for a home.

Hard mapleRed oak
Hardness (Janka, per Lauzon)14501290
GrainClear and delicateOpen, easy to see
Natural colourCreamy white to light reddish brownGold to dark brown
Example on FloorBoxLauzon Lodge Ridge hard mapleLauzon Lodge Tahoe red oak

Is maple harder than oak?

Yes, hard maple is a little harder. Lauzon, the Québec maker of Expert floors sold on FloorBox, rates wood with the Janka scale. It measures how much force it takes to press a steel ball into the wood. A higher number means the wood resists dents better.

  • Hard maple: 1450. Lauzon calls it "the hardest of all maples."
  • Red oak: 1290. Lauzon calls it "the most popular species in North America."

Lauzon says hard maple is about 12% harder than red oak. It also says both are among the best species for a home floor: hard enough to resist dents, but not so hard that they are hard to cut and nail.

One thing to watch: "maple" is not always hard maple. Lauzon gives red maple 950 and silver maple 700. So read the Species line on the product page. The FloorBox maple floors from Lauzon list Hard Maple.

What do oak and maple floors look like?

  • Maple has a fine, quiet grain. Lauzon describes it as "clear and delicate," with colours from creamy white to light reddish brown.
  • Red oak has an open grain that is easy to see. Lauzon describes "a unique open wood grain" and "a rich color scheme, from gold to dark brown."

Both come in many stained colours, not only natural. On FloorBox, you will see natural, grey and brown tones in both species. Look at the photos on each product page, and check the grade too.

What does the grade mean?

The grade tells you how much natural character shows: knots, darker streaks and colour changes. Lauzon uses four grades, from the most even to the most rustic:

  • Select & Better: even look, subtle colour changes, very few small knots.
  • Exclusive: mostly even, with some darker shades.
  • Tradition: moderate to strong colour changes, with knots and mineral streaks.
  • Character: all the natural marks of the wood, with strong colour changes.

So check the grade as well as the species. A Character red oak and a Select & Better maple will not look alike.

Can I put oak or maple hardwood in my basement?

It depends on how the floor is built, not on the species. Lauzon's spec sheets say:

  • Its solid hardwood is nailed or stapled over 3/4 in. plywood or OSB, on main and upper floors, and is not for radiant heat.
  • Its engineered hardwood (Solid 2-Ply) can go in the basement too, and can be stapled, glued or floated.

So for a basement, look at engineered oak or maple, and confirm with the maker's installation guide. Our post Hardwood Flooring vs Engineered Flooring explains the difference. You can browse Hardwood and Engineered Hardwood.

So, oak or maple?

  • Pick maple if you want a light, even look and the harder of the two.
  • Pick red oak if you like a visible grain and warm tones.
  • Either way, choose the grade you like, and pick solid or engineered based on the room.

See all the Lauzon floors on the Lauzon Expert page. Still unsure? Contact us.

Want a pattern instead of straight planks? See What Are the Main Hardwood Floor Patterns?

Frequently asked questions

Which is more durable, oak or maple?

Both are durable. Hard maple is a bit harder: 1450 on the Janka scale, compared with 1290 for red oak, according to Lauzon. That means maple resists dents a little better.

Is white oak the same as red oak?

No, they are two kinds of oak. The Janka numbers in this post are Lauzon's numbers for red oak. If you like a white oak floor, check its own product page.

Is maple hardwood made in Canada?

Lauzon says its Expert floors, in hard maple and red oak, are harvested, designed and made in Québec. Check the origin on each product page.

Can oak or maple go over a heated floor?

Lauzon's solid hardwood spec sheet says it is not compatible with radiant heat. Check the Radiant Heat Compatible line on each product page before you buy.